Wednesday, July 13, 2016

Pitch Wars Prep #5: Making Your Mentor Picks

I CHOOSE YOU!!

When the Pitch Wars mentor blog hop goes live, there will be A LOT of mentors for you to choose from. You might feel overwhelmed looking at the list of names, knowing you have to narrow it down to your top 4 choices. So today I'll be sharing some of the strategies I used last year as a mentee hopeful to narrow down my list. 

The first and most important rule of choosing a mentor is to make sure you submit only to those mentors that want both your age group AND your genre. 

I cannot stress this enough. I know all of the mentors are amazing and you've probably checked them out on Twitter and there are a couple you think are super cool and you may even have your heart set on subbing to them, but when the wish lists go live, it doesn't matter that you both love nachos and that Kimmy Schmidt is your spirit animal, too. If your genre is not on their list DO NOT SUB TO THEM. The reason we have these wish lists is because we all prefer, and have better knowledge of, certain genres. If, after reading their wish list, you're not sure if a mentor would be interested in your specific genre, don't be afraid to ask! But subbing to a mentor who has specifically said they don't want your genre is not only a waste of an entry, it shows a lack of care and respect for the mentors and the submission process.

Now that you've pinkie sworn not to sub outside your genre, here are my tips for narrowing down your selection and finding the perfect mentor. This is actually very similar to the process I used for coming up with an agent list when I started querying my first novel. One of the many perks of Pitch Wars is that it's great practice for the leg work and research required when querying agents!

1. Read through the mentors' wish lists and write down the names of those who want your genre. 

2. Using your list, make a second pass and pay attention to the details.

It's important to read ALL the information the mentors provide to determine who is most likely to connect with your story. Just because a mentor wants your genre doesn't mean they're the best fit for your particular book. What do I mean? Last year, I submitted a MG fantasy. There were plenty of MG mentors who wanted fantasy submissions, but most of them went into further detail. Some explained that they weren't interested in stories that involved portals to other worlds, or that they weren't fans of talking animals. Since my book included both of those things, I crossed those mentors off my list. Again, it's just good etiquette to respect the mentors' requests, and finding a wish list that really meshes with your book is going to give you the best shot at being chosen as a mentee.

3. Come up with a wish list ranking system.

As you scrutinize the lists, it can be really helpful to use a ranking system to keep track of which lists best fit your book. For me, this meant I put one star by anyone whose list was a general fit for my novel, two stars for a list that was a good match, and three stars for a list that was a perfect match. 

4. Get to know your top mentor picks.

Once you have your mentor picks narrowed down to say your top 5-10, it's all about getting to know them better. You can do this by reading the mentor mini-interviews, following and interacting with mentors on Twitter, and watching the live Pitch Wars mentor chats. Whose strengths are your weaknesses? Whose personality do you think you would click with? Whose favorite book is one of your comp titles? These are all things to take into consideration so that you can make those excruciating final cuts.

5. Make your final choices.

I know, there are so many amazing mentors. There were last year, too (and many of them have returned this year) so trust me when I say I feel your pain when it comes to making your final choice! But if you're willing to put in the time and effort to do your research, you can submit with confidence, knowing that you've done your best to put your manuscript into the right hands.

And don't forget! Brenda is offering 2 extra submission slots to Pitch Wars donors who give $20 or more! Which means you'll only have to narrow your list down to 6 mentors instead of 4. Details here
*All mentors are donating their time to Pitch Wars and mentors do not have access to any donation records. Whether a potential mentee donates or not has zero influence on the mentors' final decisions.

Pitch Wars is fast approaching and I can't wait to share my wish list with you!! Here's a sneak peek at my favorite books list. ;)




1 comment: